1970 Marlborough by-election

1970 Marlborough by-election
Turnout	14,730 (78.31%)
MP before election; Tom Shand; National	Elected MP ; Ian Brooks; Labour

The Marlborough by-election of 1970 was a by-election for the electorate of Marlborough, held on 21 February 1970^[1]^[2] during the 30th New Zealand Parliament.

Background

The by-election resulted from the death of Tom Shand on 11 December 1969, only 12 days after he (and the government) had been re-elected on 29 November; and the new National candidate was defeated by the greatest swing against a government since the 1935 general election, in what was a largely rural electorate generally regarded a safe National seat. Tom Shand had held the seat from 1946, when he defeated Labour’s Ted Meachen.

Candidates

Labour

The Labour Party selected Ian Brooks as their candidate. In 1969 he had stood in the electorate.^[3]

National

There were five nominees who came forward for the National Party candidacy:^[4]^[5]

Bruno Dalliessi, the Mayor of Picton
R. J. Doak, a farmer from Amberley who was National's 1969 campaign manager in Rangiora
R. W. Palmer, a farmer from Wairau Valley
Norra Woodbane Pomare, a farmer from Wellington who was National's candidate for Southern Maori in 1969
Anthony "Andy" Shand, a farmer and member of the Kaikoura County Council – son of the previous member

Shand was chosen to contest the seat at the party selection committee meeting.^[6]

Social Credit

There were two candidates for the Social Credit Party nomination:^[7]

George Kerr, a farmer from Seddon
Jeremy Woodhall, a registered surveyor from Blenheim

Kerr was selected. It was the seventh consecutive time he had contested the seat, having done so at every previous election since 1954.^[8]

Campaign

The vote for Tom Shand had been close in 1966. Labour only decided that the seat was winnable in January, and sent in two MPs Arthur Faulkner and Colin Moyle to organise the campaign. Labour's candidate, Brooks, was local; he was a senior clerk in the Picton manual telephone exchange and also had a small farm. The seat was largely rural, but Brooks polled particularly well in Picton, and well in the other two population centres, Blenheim and Kaikōura. At the end of the campaign there was some criticism of Andy Shand for frequent "butting-in" during a combined television broadcast appearance for all the candidates on Wednesday 17 February.^[9]

Results

The following table gives the election results:

1970 Marlborough by-election^[10]
Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	Labour	Ian Brooks	7,060	47.93	+9.29
	National	Andy Shand	6,017	40.85
	Social Credit	George Kerr	1,171	7.95	−0.29
	Country Party	Clifford Stanley Emeny	482	3.27
Majority			1,043	7.08
Turnout			14,730	78.31	−13.33
Registered electors			18,809

The election-night margin to Labour of 1131 was so great that the final result was not expected to change when special votes, which generally tended to go to National, were counted.^[11] There were 32 informal votes.^[12]

George Chapman was the Wellington National Party chairman. He heard reports that all was not well in the campaign, the party was in deep trouble, and that Labour was making an all-out effort. But he found that party president Ned Holt was complacent about the by-election; saying that everything was in order, and that in any case National's majority in Marlborough was big enough to absorb any setback. But on by-election night Labour inflicted a stunning defeat on National, reducing the Government majority from six to four, and shaking party confidence. Chapman became the leader for change in the organisation, resulting in his nomination for party president in 1971, although he did not become president until 1973.^[13]

Despite winning a surprise victory in 1969, National was so embarrassed from the by-election defeat it triggered the media to seriously speculate about Prime Minister Keith Holyoake's retirement.^[14]

Notes

^ New Zealand Official Yearbook 1970 p1137
^ Wood, G. A. (1996) [1987]. Ministers and Members in the New Zealand Parliament (2 ed.). Dunedin: University of Otago Press. p. 113. ISBN 1 877133 00 0.
^ "Labour Choice Of Candidate". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32206. 27 January 1970. p. 13.
^ "Five Seek Nomination". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32191. 9 January 1970. p. 1.
^ "Five Wanted to Stand". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32192. 10 January 1970. p. 10.
^ "Mr Shand's Son to Contest By-election". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32196. 15 January 1970. p. 12.
^ "Social Credit Nominations". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32193. 12 January 1970. p. 8.
^ "Candidate Chosen". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32195. 14 January 1970. p. 26.
^ "Marlborough By-election". The Dominion. 20 February 1970. p. 3.
^ Norton 1988, p. 274.
^ "Labour wins Marlborough By-election". The Dominion. 23 February 1970. p. 3.
^ Norton 1988, pp. 274, 410.
^ Chapman, George (1980). The Years of Lightning. Wellington: AH & AW Reed. pp. 44–45. ISBN 0-589-01346-7.
^ Wood, G. A. "Holyoake, Keith Jacka". Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Ministry for Culture and Heritage. Retrieved 30 October 2012.

References

Norton, Clifford (1988). New Zealand Parliamentary Election Results 1946–1987: Occasional Publications No 1, Department of Political Science. Wellington: Victoria University of Wellington. ISBN 0-475-11200-8.

[1] New Zealand Official Yearbook 1970 p1137

[2] Wood, G. A. (1996) [1987]. Ministers and Members in the New Zealand Parliament (2 ed.). Dunedin: University of Otago Press. p. 113. ISBN 1 877133 00 0.

[3] "Labour Choice Of Candidate". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32206. 27 January 1970. p. 13.

[4] "Five Seek Nomination". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32191. 9 January 1970. p. 1.

[5] "Five Wanted to Stand". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32192. 10 January 1970. p. 10.

[6] "Mr Shand's Son to Contest By-election". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32196. 15 January 1970. p. 12.

[7] "Social Credit Nominations". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32193. 12 January 1970. p. 8.

[8] "Candidate Chosen". The Press. Vol. CX, no. 32195. 14 January 1970. p. 26.

[9] "Marlborough By-election". The Dominion. 20 February 1970. p. 3.

[FOOTNOTENorton1988274-10] Norton 1988, p. 274.

[11] "Labour wins Marlborough By-election". The Dominion. 23 February 1970. p. 3.

[FOOTNOTENorton1988274,_410-12] Norton 1988, pp. 274, 410.

[13] Chapman, George (1980). The Years of Lightning. Wellington: AH & AW Reed. pp. 44–45. ISBN 0-589-01346-7.

[dnzb-14] Wood, G. A. "Holyoake, Keith Jacka". Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Ministry for Culture and Heritage. Retrieved 30 October 2012.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

v t e « (1912–1938) « By-elections in New Zealand in the two-party era (1939–1995) » (1996–present) »
26th Parliament	Christchurch South, 1939 Auckland West, 1940 Waipawa, 1940 Waitemata, 1941 Bay of Plenty, 1941 Mid-Canterbury, 1942 Temuka, 1942 Hauraki, 1942 Christchurch East, 1943 Northern Maori, 1943
27th Parliament	Awarua, 1944 Western Maori, 1945 Hamilton, 1945 Dunedin North, 1945 Raglan, 1946
28th Parliament	Avon, 1947 Mount Albert, 1947 Westland, 1947
29th Parliament	Brooklyn, 1951
30th Parliament	Dunedin North, 1953 Onehunga, 1953 Onslow, 1954 Patea, 1954
31st Parliament	Riccarton, 1956 Bay of Plenty, 1957
32nd Parliament	Hamilton, 1959
33rd Parliament	Hurunui, 1961 Waitaki, 1962 Buller, 1962 Timaru, 1962 Otahuhu, 1963 Northern Maori, 1963 Grey Lynn, 1963
34th Parliament	There were no by-elections during the term of the 34th Parliament.
35th Parliament	Southern Maori, 1967 Fendalton, 1967 Petone, 1967 Palmerston North, 1967 Eastern Maori, 1967 Hutt, 1968
36th Parliament	Marlborough, 1970
37th Parliament	Sydenham, 1974
38th Parliament	Nelson, 1976 Mangere, 1977 Pahiatua, 1977 Rangitikei, 1978
39th Parliament	Christchurch Central, 1979 Northern Maori, 1980 Onehunga, 1980 East Coast Bays, 1980
40th Parliament	There were no by-elections during the term of the 40th Parliament.
41st Parliament	Timaru, 1985
42nd Parliament	There were no by-elections during the term of the 42nd Parliament.
43rd Parliament	Tamaki, 1992 Wellington Central, 1992 Tauranga, 1993
44th Parliament	Selwyn, 1994