Jump to content

Talk:Maisie Ward

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Neutral?

[edit]

There seem to be a number of distinctly non-NPOV statements in this article:

  • "most of what was good about the Second Vatican Council"
  • "a book which, to this day, remains as galvanizing on its subject as is Chesterton’s own on St. Thomas Aquinas"
  • "Caryll Houselander (another wrongly overlooked voice)"
  • "their felicitous pairing."

Are we quoting an authoratative source on what were the good parts of Vatican 2, the merits of Ward's and Chesterton's biographies, Houselander's obscurity, or felicity of the Ward/Sheed marriage? Because, if not, I don't think any of those statements belong in Wikipedia.

The article's short on sources too.

Chuntuk (talk) 12:19, 18 May 2015 (UTC)[reply]