Talk:National Register of Historic Places listings in Salt Lake City

Kingsbury Hall

Should Kingsbury Hall on the University of Utah campus be listed on this page? The source in the article says it is on the register. UteFan16 (talk) 05:39, 22 September 2009 (UTC)

It's actually here as part of the University of Utah Circle, a historic district that is listed on the Register. Many websites erroneously claim that contributing properties to districts on the Register are separately listed on the Register, and this is one of them. Nyttend (talk) 13:08, 22 September 2009 (UTC)

Historic Districts

The section needs to be split into two, one showing individual sites outside historic districts and other showing the historic districts with corresponding maps. There are too many historic districts with listed individual sites already listed without any indication of which sites are located within the districts. I know because I live in one of these districts and formerly lived in other districts. Several of these districts abut each other. Samuelsenwd (talk) 18:52, 21 September 2014 (UTC)

This list is just a summary. The intention is for each listing, including every district, to have its own article. It's just that a lot of them have yet to be created. Ntsimp (talk) 03:58, 22 September 2014 (UTC)

Collection of Utah State docs in NPS's Warehouse District doc

There is a collection of Utah State Historical Society documents (Structure/Site Information forms) available, for numerous SLC sites, all in one 84 page PDF. The PDF is served up by the National Park Service at https://npgallery.nps.gov/NRHP/GetAsset/NRHP/82004149_text. Which is, however, the location where one would expect for a NRHP registration/nomination document for the original listing of the Warehouse District (Salt Lake City, Utah) (NRHP-listed August 17, 1982, reference number 82004149). (The Warehouse District was later greatly increased in size by a boundary increase listing on March 22, 2016, refnum=16000125.) Oddly, most or all of the sites covered in the collection are NOT in the original or later-expanded Warehouse District! Many are on Main Street (formerly East Temple St.), which is not at all in the Warehouse District. (This was pointed out to me by Tamanoeconomico. Thanks User:Tamanoeconomico! )

The sites covered, with various related notes, are as follows ( and  Done indicates the corresponding article has been edited to include a reference to its Utah doc from this collection):

1. McIntyre Building (1908-09), architect Richard Kletting, "the earliest and best example of Sullivanesque architecture in the state" (besides the Dooly Building, demolished, designed by Louis Sullivan himself). Separately NRHP-listed in 1977.  Done
2. ZCMI Cast Iron Front Separately NRHP-listed. On Main St., not in Warehouse District.
3. McCornick Building, also known as Crandall Building. McCornick Building was separately NRHP-listed in 1977.
4. Daft Block, Daynes Jewelry Building. On Main St., not in WD, the Daft Block was separately NRHP-listed in 1976.
5. Tracy Loan and Trust Company Building, separately NRHP-listed in 1978.
6. First National Bank (Salt Lake City, Utah)
7. Herald Building (1905)
8. Utah Savings and Trust Co. Building (1888), 235 So. Main St. (THIS IS NOT the Utah Commercial and Savings Bank Building separately listed in 1975.) The "Savings and Trust Company Building" is "one of Utah's earliest commercial buildings to utilize a reinforced concrete structural system." Designed by architects Ware and Treganza of Salt Lake City...." Seems NOT nrhp-listed.
9. Karrick Block, designed by Richard Kletting, NRHP-listed  Done
10. Lollin Block (1894), designed by Richard Kletting, NRHP-listed  Done
11. Keith–O'Brien Building (or Keith O'Brien Building ?) (1902), designed by Frederick Albert Hale, NRHP-listed in 1977
12. Oregon Shortline Railroad Company Bldg./Salt Lake High School Armory Bldg./Western Newspaper Union Bldg. (1897-98) Oregon Shortline Railroad Company Building, separately NRHP-listed in 1976.
13. Independent Order of Odd Fellows Hall, 41 Post Office Place per this (moved in 2009 per its article), NRHP-listed in 1977. Add about 5 million pound weight. List of largest buildings moved? List of largest things moved to include NASA rockets etc. Bridges moved into place at end of construction? One in Boston Dig.
14. New York Hotel (1906), 42 Post Office Place, Richard Kletting-designed, NRHP-listed in 1980  Done
15. Utah Commercial and Savings Bank, 20 E. 100 South, Richard Kletting, NRHP-listed in 1975
16. J. A. Fritsch Block/Guthrie Cyclery (1890), 158 East 200 South, Richardsonian Romanesque, NRHP-listed in 1976
17. Orpheum/Capitol Theatre (1912-13), 46 West 200 South, NRHP-listed in 1976
18. Bertolini Block, NRHP-listed in 1976
19. J. G. McDonald Chocolate Company Bldg (1901), NRHP-listed in 1978
20. Peery Hotel (1910), NRHP-listed in 1978
21. Salt Lake Union Pacific Railroad Station (article at Salt Lake City Union Pacific Depot (1908-09), NRHP-listed
22. Denver and Rio Grande Railroad Station (article at Denver and Rio Grande Western Depot (Salt Lake City), NRHP-listed
23. Hogar Hotel/Lewis S. Hills Residence Hogar Hotel Lewis S. Hills Residence Lewis S. Hills House (article at Lewis S. Hills House (126 S. 200 West), NRHP-listed
24. Salt Lake City Public Library (Hansen Planetarium) Salt Lake City Public Library Hansen Planetarium (article at Old Hansen Planetarium, NRHP-listed

Note for many/most of these there is a regular NRHP document available which has content often overlapping, and not independent of, the Utah State forms. But it seems useful to refer to the (presumably older) Utah State forms, too.

About referencing "UtahDocsCollection"

I am composing corresponding references to use in each separate site article in format like: <ref name=nrhpdoc-UtahDocsCollection-SITE>{{cite web|url={{NRHP url|id=82004149}}|title=Utah State Historical Society Structure/Site Information: SITE |publisher=[[National Park Service]]|author= |date= |accessdate=May 22, 2019}}<!---no pics doc---> (PDF pages __; appears __th in collection of forms for numerous SLC buildings)</ref> where "nrhpdoc-UtahDocsCollection-SITE" is the reference name.

E.g. for Karrick Block (which has a discernable author named):

<ref name=nrhpdoc-UtahDocsCollection-Karrick> {{cite web|url={{NRHP url|id=82004149}} |title=Utah State Historical Society Structure/Site Information: Karrick Block |publisher=[[National Park Service]] |author=Lorraine Pace |date=September 17, 1979 |accessdate=May 22, 2019}} (PDF pages 32-35; appears 10th in collection of forms for numerous SLC buildings)</ref>

see the "Karrick Block" reference authored by Lorraine Pace in the following:

References

I am noting this also at wp:NRIS info issues UT. --Doncram (talk) 16:05, 24 May 2019 (UTC)

Old Pioneer Fort Site

Should Old Pioneer Fort Site link to Pioneer Park (Salt Lake City)? ---Another Believer _(Talk) 00:31, 14 May 2021 (UTC)