Jump to content

Wikipedia:New pages patrol/Backlog drives/January 2024/Re-reviews

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

To re-review articles, list your name below followed by a numbered list of the articles you have re-reviewed. To find articles to re-review, go to Wikipedia:Database reports/Top new article reviewers, pick any editor, and visit the log to find articles that they have reviewed since the start of the drive. Make sure to note the original reviewer and whether the original review was correct. If you found problems with the original review, please discuss it with the original reviewer on the backlog drive talk page.

DreamRimmer

  1. Ashok Attri (diplomat)Mattdaviesfsic Fails to meet WP:GNG, diplomats need to pass WP:GNG or WP:ANYBIO for a standalone article. The sources in the articles are standard press releases/notifications.
  2. Ramzi AbedMattdaviesfsic Fails to meet WP:GNG or WP:NDIRECTOR; not a single source mentions his name, and he directed non-notable films.
  1. Lifeline (Alicia Keys song)Hey man im josh: No issues, good patrol.
  2. 2024 Oregon Democratic presidential primaryHey man im josh: No issues, good patrol.
  1. Park Jin-hee (general) - FULBERT: should not have been marked reviewed per NPPDEL since I had already tagged the article with BLPPROD. Left a message on FULBERT's talk page.
  1. Alana Murphy - Hughesdarren: marked as reviewed, but the article only had one primary source; no maintenance tags were added. Without further searching, it's unclear if the subject meets WP:NSPORT. Further, there are three empty section headings. I've draftified the article and left a message on Hughesdarren's page.
  2. Ella O'Grady - Hughesdarren: marked as reviewed, but the article only had one primary source; no maintenance tags were added. Without further searching, it's unclear if the subject meets WP:NSPORT. Further, there are three empty section headings. I've draftified the article and left a message on Hughesdarren's page.
  3. Aliah Raga - Hey man im josh: Questionable good review. The article had two independent sources with SIGCOV to pass NSPORT, but someone later noted that the sources didn't verify the information (i.e., they were published months before the event). However, verifying information isn't specifically required in a review. The sources have since been removed, but the subject is notable; there are now maintenance tags.
  4. Ana Luiza Franceschi - Ipigott: Mostly good review. Franceschi meets WP:NGYMNAST for medaling at the Junior World Championships. However, I would suggest adding a maintenance tag for third-party sources as the only sources provided are score sheets.
  5. Amanda Bosch - Raydann: Meets WP:NGYMNAST and has independent sources. Good review. :)
  6. Draft:NKTV Plus - Maliner: Appropriate draftifty.
  7. Tarlatamab - Maliner: Overall good review, but should have added a maintenance tag to indicate the article needs more sources.
  8. Draft:Kirby & Friends - Eternal Shadow: Article was appropriately draftified due to a lack of sources, but it was done too soon; the article was only about 30 minutes old.
  9. Alexy Vega - FULBERT: Inappropriate draftification; the article had already been draftified in October.
  10. Draft:Richard Maximilian Akwei - FULBERT: Appropriate draftification of an article without any sources.
  11. Draft:Copper Development Association UK - Maliner: Inappropriate draftification; although the article may be draftified in the future (no sources), it had been edited 7 minutes earlier by the article's creator. I left a note on Maliner's talk page.
  12. Draft:Monkey mart - Maliner: Inappropriate draftification; although the article may be draftified in the future (no sources), it had been edited 22 minutes earlier by the article's creator.
  13. Draft:2024 Upper Austria Ladies Linz – Singles - Maliner: Another draftification that occurred too soon, though only 7 minutes before the one-hour mark.
  14. Draft:Alnoor Society - Maliner: Yet another too soon draftication; this article had been created 45 minutes earlier.
  15. The Fable (film) - Pichpich: Meets WP:NFILM; good review
  16. Blackwoods Beach - Stuartyeates: Likely meets WP:NGEO per WP:GEONATURAL, but at present, there aren't sources to pass GNG. I have tagged it as relying on a single source.
  17. Jewel Eyed Judy - Hey man im josh: Passes WP:NSONG; good review
  18. Turkestan Arena - CycloneYoris: Article was appropriately tagged for CSD A3 given it only had an infobox; however, the article had been edited in the previously 30 minutes by a new editor (fewer than 30 edits)
  19. AQ Mart - CycloneYoris: Article was tagged for CSD A7, which is likely appropriate; however, the article had been edited in the previous 30 minutes by a new editor (fewer than 30 edits)
  20. Alexandra Herrera - Ipigott: Passes WP:NSPORT, good review.
  21. Alla Biletska - Bastun: Passes WP:NSPORT, good review.
  22. Anastasia Blayvas - Dcotos: Fails WP:NSPORT as all sources are databases; however, sources likely exist since she received a bronze medal at the youth olympics (weightlifting doesn't have SNG).
  23. Andrea Zryd - DreamRimmer: Passes WP:NPOL; good review
  24. Anna Gandler - Ipigott: Passes WP:NATH, but relies solely on a database source; I've added a maintenance tag
  25. April Angurasaranee - Ipigott: Passes NSPORT; good review
  26. Eman Waseem - Maliner: Meets WP:NPOL; good review
  27. Draft:Latvia (1918-1940) - Bruxton: Draftified the article 6 minutes after it had been created. Sure, the article was only an infobox, but the creator only has 24 edits. I've reached out to Bruxton
No problem. DreamRimmer (talk) 11:05, 9 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]
  1. List of Scotland ODI cricketers JTtheOG marked reviewed good patrol
  2. MS Borgestad Pickersgill-Cunliffe marked reviewed good patrol
  3. Silver Nova Pickersgill-Cunliffe marked reviewed good patrol
  4. 125 kilometer Praseodymium-141 Marked as reviewed - orphan with no categories - an unreferenced paragraph - and dubious references I unreviewed and notified the reviewer
  5. Farad, California Praseodymium-141 Marked as reviewed - orphan with no categories - an unreferenced paragraph - and dubious references I unreviewed and notified the reviewer. I do not think this would survive an AfD with our WP:GEOLAND guide.
  6. Emily Blumberg Significa liberdade unreviewed the article but it was likely a mistake. The person meets WP:NPROF. I messaged on their talk page.
  7. Andra Blomkalns Significa liberdade unreviewed the article but it was likely a mistake. The person meets WP:NPROF. I messaged on their talk page.
  8. Western Harbour Tunnel Robertsky marked reviewed good patrol
  9. Big ring NotAGenious marked reviewed good patrol
  10. Van Cleave, Kentucky Tails Wx marked reviewed good patrol
  11. Citrus margarita TechnoSquirrel69 marked reviewed good patrol
  12. Ive TechnoSquirrel69 marked reviewed good patrol
  13. Kaprosuchus Chaotic Enby marked reviewed good patrol
  14. Gaza Strip famine Chaotic Enby marked reviewed good patrol
  15. Eastern dwarf hornbill Chaotic Enby marked reviewed good patrol
  16. Ramzan Lanka official Maliner CSD good patrol
  17. Douglas Abraham Maliner marked reviewed good patrol
  18. Jurica Ružić Maliner article tagged and marked reviewed good patrol
  19. List of storms named Candice Maliner marked unreviewed - article was later marked reviewed by Hey man im josh so probably not a good patrol
  20. Barrancos ham Scope creep marked reviewed good patrol
  21. Taylor Burkhart Scope creep marked reviewed good patrol
  22. Aaron Daniel Jacob Rosguill marked reviewed good patrol
  23. Donkey Kong Rosguill marked reviewed good patrol
  24. Jaime Zapata (footballer) Rosguill marked reviewed good patrol
  25. String Ting FULBERT tagged for notability good patrol
  26. Zak Schwank FULBERT marked reviewed good patrol
No issues DreamRimmer (talk) 11:06, 9 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]
  1. List of states with cities larger than their capital city by population@Dr vulpes: should not have been marked as reviewed, topic is already covered by other existing lists and is not notable enough itself for a standalone list. Nominated for deletion, left message at Dr vulpes's talk page.
  2. Glossonotus@Dr vulpes: good review, passes notability, no problems.
  3. Abdul Majeed (politician)@Justiyaya: good review, passes notability, no problems.
  4. Samuel Boan@Justiyaya: good review, passes notability, no problems.
  1. Economy of the State of HidalgoFULBERT – correctly tagged with multiple tags
  2. Sabina RgayevaJTtheOG – correctly sent to AfD as borderline GNG
  3. Fire ShieldSunDawn – no issues
  4. List of mayors of Galveston, TexasPickersgill-Cunliffe – no issues
  5. Van Cleave, KentuckyTails Wx – no issues
  6. Mississauga—StreetsvilleHey man im josh – DAB no issues
  7. List of World Heritage Sites in HaitiRatnahastin – no issues
  8. Eastern dwarf hornbillChaotic Enby – no issues
  9. Ava ReidKj cheetham – no issues
  10. Hezbollah-Russia relationsA412 – I added unreliable sources tag
  11. Golam Sarwar TukuMaliner – Correctly tagged at review (since improved)
  12. 2024 Texas State Bobcats football teamWikiOriginal-9 – Correctly tagged one source
  13. Abdul Majeed (politician)Justiyaya – no issues
  14. List of World Heritage Sites in NicaraguaDr vulpes – no issues
  15. Larca bosselaersiHughesdarren – no issues
  16. A Guilty ConscienceSignifica liberdade – DAB no issues
  17. Wonderful World of RomanceRosguill – no issues
  18. 2024 Mexico City ePrixFuzzyMagma – no issues
  19. The Trust: A Game of GreedBatsun – correctly tagged 3rd party and refimprove – Not marked as reviewed by Batsun (or myself)
  20. Charles William KikerMPGuy2824 – no issues
  21. Janhit Abhiyan vs Union of IndiaZI Jony – Correctly tagged more categories
  22. From Fall to SpringDarling – Correctly tagged copy edit
  23. 2024 Mexican local electionsStuartyeates – Correctly tagged one source
  24. S/2006 S 9JeBonSer – no issues
  25. Kakinada Assembly constituencyUmakant Bhalerao – no issues
  26. Alleluia! Sing to JesusScope creep – no issues
  27. Bishnu KhadkaPraseodymium-141 – correctly tagged notability (needs a Nepelase expert to assess sources)
  28. Wild ScandinaviaBuySomeApples – no issues
  29. James Van PattenCielquiparle – Reviewer added multiple tags including CSD – article is now at AfD
  30. Trouble for LuciaDcotos – no issues
Good DreamRimmer (talk) 11:07, 9 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]
  1. Rangers (sports team) patrolled by Joseywales1961 - sent to AfD
  1. Sandra HazlehurstKj cheetham – meets WP:GNG, no issues, good patrol
  2. Ivonne NúñezKj cheetham – meets WP:NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  3. Ofelia EsparzaKj cheetham – meets GNG, correctly tagged cat improve, good patrol
  4. Jane RosenbergKj cheetham – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  5. Renata CarvalhoKj cheetham – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  6. Barnardia numidicaChaotic Enby – meets WP:NSPECIES, no issues, good patrol
  7. Kifrawi KifliChaotic Enby – meets NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  8. Barry Gough (businessman)Chaotic Enby – not enough sources, correctly moved to draftspace, good patrol
  9. 2024 Istanbul mayoral electionChaotic Enby – no issues, good patrol
  10. Clivia robustaChaotic Enby – meets NSPECIES, no issues, good patrol
  11. Germie BernardJustiyaya – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  12. What Moves the DeadJustiyaya – meets WP:NBOOK, no issues, good patrol
  13. Begonia luzhaiensisJustiyaya – meets NSPECIES, no issues, good patrol
  14. Can AtalayMPGuy2824 – meets NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  15. Tanvir ChowdhuryStuartyeates – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  16. 2024 Oregon State Beavers baseball teamStuartyeates – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  17. Oscar CalderonFULBERT – meets GNG, correctly tagged with multiple tags, good patrol
  18. Rupinder Singh KoonerUmakant Bhalerao – meets NPOLITICIAN, correctly tagged as uncategorized, good patrol
  19. Lochana MundaUmakant Bhalerao – Possible GNG fail, no evidence of WP:SIGCOV and I don't believe I found any in Odia sources, questionable patrol... Sent to AfD and left message at user's talk page
  20. Lalchhandama RalteUmakant Bhalerao – meets NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  21. Mellissa HeermannUmakant Bhalerao – meets NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  22. Farès GhedjemisIngratis – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  23. Diby KeitaUtopes – poorly sourced BLP, no evidence of WP:SIGCOV, should have added tags at least, questionable patrol
  24. Jesse Carrasquedo Jr.Utopes – probably a GNG fail, correctly sent to AfD, good patrol
  25. Troy PurcellBruxton – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  26. Jagodno, WrocławThe Night Watch – no issues, good patrol
  27. Sons of RamsesYeeno – meets WP:NFILM, no issues, good patrol
  28. 1984 Chester City Council electionYeeno – no issues, good patrol
  29. Dubivka, Ternopil OblastYeeno – no issues, good patrol
No problem. DreamRimmer (talk) 11:07, 9 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]

SunDawn

  1. 2024 GT World Challenge AsiaHey man im josh - Good patrol, no issue.
  2. Addison and Hedgefield ReserveHey man im josh - Good patrol, no issue.
  3. Lewisham (electoral division)Hey man im josh - Good patrol, no issue here.
  4. 2011 Transat Jacques VabreHey man im josh - Good patrol, no issue.
  5. Grant Taylor (baseball)Hey man im josh - Good patrol, no issue.
  6. Nathan Webb (baseball)Hey man im josh - Good patrol, no issue.
  7. Townsendia grandifloraHey man im josh - Good patrol, no issue.
  8. CyliosomaTails Wx - Good patrol, no issue.
  9. Creaserinus claususTails Wx - Good patrol, no issue.
  10. View from RouellesTails Wx - Good patrol, no issue.
  11. Will PaulingTails Wx - Good patrol, no issue.
  12. Cyrtolobus togatusTails Wx - Good patrol, no issue.
  13. Sierra Vista Open Space PreserveTails Wx - Good patrol, no issue.
  14. SROSS-C2A412 - Good patrol, no issue.
  15. AstraSatA412 - Good patrol, no issue.
  16. USA-339A412 - Good patrol, no issue.
  17. Prishtina ObservatoryA412 - Good patrol, no issue.
  18. CICERO-6A412 - Good patrol, no issue.
  19. HSwMS Malmö (P12)A412 - Good patrol, no issue.
  20. McCash FireKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  21. Royal Defence CommandKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  22. HumoAirKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  23. Taghanic eventKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  24. Hazira Gas Processing ComplexKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  25. Mmadinare Solar Power StationKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  26. Pirapora Solar ComplexKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  27. Hayasat-1Kj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  28. Urdaneta-ArmsatKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
  29. CHIO RotterdamKj cheetham - Good patrol, no issue.
Checked, no issues. DreamRimmer (talk) 11:08, 9 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]
  1. Sugar Zaza - SunDawn - Passes COPYVIO check but the subject isn't notable
  2. Hampden Gurney Primary School - SunDawn - Passes COPYVIO check; Schools typically are not notable and we have to examine for UPE advertising but this is notable, if only for the architecture.
  3. Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School, Rajshahi - SunDawn - Passes COPYVIO check; good PROD; the author, of course, reverted you so I sent to AfD.
  4. The Sound of Love (album) - A412 - Passes COPYVIO check; assuming a lot of good faith that subject passes NALBUMS because Billboard says a single on it charted.
  5. Ryan Tudhope- A412 - Subject fails ANYBIO: I sent to AfD
  6. Chris Dessi- A412 - good AfD nom
  7. Colombian displacement crisis - PK650 - I don't think this subject is notable and I left a note on the talk page
  8. Alan Bates (subpostmaster) - Markdask - subject of notable legal case and now a recent TV show so WP:BLP1E no longer applies.
  9. Marlon Hunt - Blaze Wolf - good CSD tag
  10. Subbalakshmi Samsara - Paul2520 - COPYVIO check fine; sourcing isn't the best but we assume a 500-episode TV show had coverage in other RS
  11. The Dream (Tamara de Lempicka) - Paul2520 - COPYVIO check fine; sourcing is poorly-done here but I found other sources that would pull it over the line for GNG
  12. Rio Grande 268 - Dan arndt - COPYVIO check fine; Assuming a lot of good faith in offline sources but I guess this is ok
  13. Facts (Tom MacDonald and Ben Shapiro song) - Dan arndt - COPYVIO check fine; enough people wrote about this although the iTunes chart doesn't count
  14. Lulu in Hollywood - Dan arndt - COPYVIO check fine; passes NBOOK
  15. Max Fashions - Darcyisverycute - Good AfD nom
  16. Hucksters.net - Darcyisverycute - Good AfD nom
  17. Fremantle Arts Centre (organisation) - Darcyisverycute - passes COPYVIO check; enough sourcing
  18. Chartism and the Eureka Rebellion - Darcyisverycute - passes COPYVIO check; enough sourcing
  19. Xinju Tian - Darcyisverycute - I merged this into Pregnancy_over_age_50#Cases_of_pregnancy_over_age_50 because three sources is not generally notable. You made a good pitch on the talk page about your choice.
  20. Gaspy - Darcyisverycute - CV check fine but I have doubts this app is notable.
  21. John Jay Schieffelin - Darcyisverycute - I have doubts about notability
  22. Social identity threat - Darcyisverycute - COPYVIO check is fine; academic articles like these are often rife with SYNTH
  23. The Senses and the Intellect - Darcyisverycute - COPVIO check fine; there are other sources not included
  24. Jacobs Ladder (exercise machine) - Darcyisverycute - COPVIO check fine; enough sources for GNG
  25. Friday Plans - Darcyisverycute - Good AfD nom
No issues. DreamRimmer (talk) 11:08, 9 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]
  1. Naci GörürFULBERT tagged the article with two notability tags – academic and biography – though I don't see how notability is an issue here. The subject passes WP:NACADEMIC #2 and passes WP:NBASIC per the references in the article. I've left a note on FULBERT's talk page concerning this.
  1. Honorary Consulate of Romania in Žilina MPGuy2824 Marked as reviewed but the article was later sent to deletion by Biruitorul
  2. Donald Hawk Crothers MPGuy2824 Marked as reviewed good patrol
  3. Licenciado Benito Juárez, Sinaloa MPGuy2824 Marked as reviewed good patrol
  4. Chris Casey (American football) Grahaml35 Sent the article to deletion but right now it is looking like a keep
  5. Ben Herbert Grahaml35 tagged and reviewed good patrol
  6. Antonio Bernardo (academic) Grahaml35 Marked as reviewed good patrol
  7. 2004 Nürburgring F3000 round Grahaml35 tagged and reviewed good patrol
  8. Ifor Fielding JTtheOG Marked as reviewed good patrol
  9. Sabina Rgayeva JTtheOG Sent to deletion good patrol
  10. Kyle Ming JTtheOG Sent to deletion good patrol
  11. Alexandra Töpfner JTtheOG Sent to deletion good patrol
  12. Aridon Bllaca JTtheOG G5 good patrol
  13. 1958 Jordan crisis Firefangledfeathers Marked as reviewed good patrol
  14. Eliza McLamb Firefangledfeathers Marked as reviewed and tagged good patrol
  15. 2024 in literature Firefangledfeathers Marked as reviewed good patrol
  16. Tom Steinfort The-Pope Marked as reviewed good patrol
  17. Ella Heads The-Pope Marked as reviewed good patrol
  18. Mathew Buck The-Pope Marked as reviewed good patrol
  19. Tim Sail The-Pope Marked as reviewed good patrol
  20. Preston Vance Utopes Marked as reviewed good patrol
  21. 2024 European Parliament election in Sweden Utopes Marked as reviewed good patrol
  22. Erving Polster Utopes Marked as reviewed good patrol
  23. Godfrey Boyle Utopes Marked as reviewed has a high Earwig score. I notified utopes
  24. Results of the 1887 Canadian federal election Ratnahastin Marked as reviewed lacks references - just one primary in the article - I tagged the article
  25. Casey Airfield Ratnahastin Marked as reviewed - notability is questionable so I tagged it
  26. Civil War in Poland (1077-1079) Ratnahastin Possible copyright violations and or WP:CLOP - I tagged the article
All are good. DreamRimmer (talk) 11:09, 9 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]
  1. Chicago rat holeFermiboson – Good review, good tagging.
  1. The Man Who Wasn't MaigretScope creep – Notable book stub, good review
  2. Karla LemsIpigott – Good review, perfectly ok political stub
  3. Liz FenwickIpigott – Good review, the author seems notable and the creator did a good job following AfC feedback. I removed a GoodReads link from the refs, but the page seems fine otherwise.
  4. Emmanuel-Alain RaynalIpigott – Good review, the filmmaker is notable and the page seems good.
  5. Dulhan parathaDreamRimmer – AfDed and ended up with consensus to merge, so that's a good review
  6. Louis SickingDreamRimmer – Good review, solid NPROF page.
  7. Judeo-EsfahaniDreamRimmer – Good review, seems like a good start on a language page
  8. Edmundo BossioJTtheOG – Good review
  9. RugosusivittaJTtheOG – Good review of a species stub, hopefully there's more information to expand it in the future.
  10. Dark Cloud (activist)JTtheOG – Good review of a notable BLP. The article had a few issues but it looks like they've all been cleaned up.
  11. Tidy TraxJTtheOG – Good review of a notable label
  12. The Language of ThornsJTtheOG – Good review, notable anthology.
  13. God's Children Are Little Broken ThingsSignifica liberdade – Good review, earwig flags quotes but there's no copyvio
  14. Do Nothing (band)Significa liberdade – Good review, solid band page
  15. William de CurtorimSunDawn – Good review of a singer's page
  16. Tolenas SpringsSunDawn – Good review, definitely meets NGEO imo
  17. 2023-2024 German farmers' protestsSunDawn – Good review, it looks like the page covers events pretty fairly
  18. Griffin SistersSunDawn – Good review, it looks like the page covers events pretty fairly
  19. Penglai riceSunDawn – Good review, this seems like a well made article
  20. LoshnitsaSunDawn – Good review, it's a legally recognized place and the page has no issues
  21. Alocasia atropurpureaSunDawn – Good review of a plant species page
  22. Five & DimeDreamRimmer – Good review, very nicely put together album page
  23. John FathereeDreamRimmer – Good review, no issues
  24. Diploglottis bernieanaJustiyaya – Good review of a plant page
  25. Freefall RacersJustiyaya – Good review, it would be nice if more of the existing reviews were used as refs but it's not necessary
  26. Victoria's owl-cloverJustiyaya – Good plant stub review
  27. Rise Up (Andra Day song)Justiyaya – Good review, no issues
  28. Songjeong station (disambiguation)Justiyaya – Good review. Was orphaned but I just added some links
  29. War on drugs in EcuadorCielquiparle – Good review, I'm sure more will be added but this is a perfectly cromulent start to an article
  30. Blida (disambiguation)Cielquiparle – Good disambig review
  31. 20th Animation StudiosSunDawn – Good CSD although it should probably have been A10 because it seems like it was a duplicate of 20th Century Animation
  32. Perception (NF album)Rosguill – Good album review
  33. Jacqueline Newman (lawyer)Kj cheetham – Good AfD, didn't quite make the cut for notability
  34. Mariya RusalenkoKj cheetham – Also a good AfD
  35. 2023–24 Ranji Trophy Group BDr vulpes – Good AfD, not a lot of participation but it's obvious this was better as a redirect to a central page
  36. 2023–24 Ranji Trophy Group CDr vulpes – Same as above
  37. 2023–24 Ranji Trophy Group DDr vulpes – Also good
  38. 2023–24 Ranji Trophy Plate GroupDr vulpes – This got deleted later as a G5, but the original nom to redirect is sound imo
  39. StraitsX Singapore DollarDr vulpes – Good AfD, I did a brief BEFORE and didn't see anything that would make me disagree with consensus
  40. World of Warcraft: The War WithinDr vulpes – Good review, some of the sources aren't great but they weren't in the article at the time it was patrolled. I went ahead and replaced them
  41. Angelic Hoodrat: SupercutDr vulpes – Good album review, the deluxe edition does seem to be notable on its own
  42. Trachytalis isabellinaDr vulpes – Good species stub, TIL what a treehopper is
  43. Trachytalis distinguendaDr vulpes – Another good species stub
  44. PlastistoneFuzzyMagma – Good review, scary topic tbh, our environment is doomed
  45. Big ringNotAGenious – Good disambig review
  46. Madagascar martinNotAGenious – Good species review
  47. Marasmius plicatulusJustiyaya – Good fungus stub review
  48. Rose SkinnerJustiyaya – Good review, no obvious issues
  49. 8 Found DeadJustiyaya – Good review, needs a plot and more links to it, but otherwise fine
  50. Lavender PattenJustiyaya – Good review, interesting sounding life
  51. Meredith PerryDr vulpes – Kept at AfD, but it was close enough that I wouldn't call this a bad review
  52. Rogelio AndaverdeTechnoSquirrel69 – Good AfD of an article that didn't meet notability, which is important when it's a crime article
  53. SheckyNotAGenious – Good disambig review
  54. Julian L. YaleInterstellarGamer12321 – Good review, no issues spotted
  55. Menneus capensisInterstellarGamer12321 – Good spider stub review
  56. Zhubei (disambiguation)WikiShovel – Good disambig review
  57. Gerald Moore (disambiguation)WikiShovel – Good disambig review
  58. Lake GabouInterstellarGamer12321 – Good review, there is a bit of close paraphrasing but nothing egregious. I reworded slightly
  59. Bryan BrinyarkInterstellarGamer12321 – Good BLP review
  60. Ned ShermanLightBurst – Good historical bio review
  61. Judith Kelleher SchaferInterstellarGamer12321 – Good NPROF review
  62. GurjaraWikiOriginal-9 – Good disambig review
  63. StenokranioWikiOriginal-9 – Good review, actually a stellar start to a species article
  64. SedercyprisWikiOriginal-9 – Good fish species review
  65. Barclaya rugosaWikiOriginal-9 – Good plant review
  66. MonomachidaeWikiOriginal-9 – Good wasp family review
  67. Big RingDarling – Good review
  68. Russian strikes on UkraineDarling – Good disambig review
  69. Gerhard Müller (politician)Darling – Good review, seems like a notable figure
  70. Gypsy, Roma and Traveller people (UK)Hughesdarren – Good review, surprising that this wasn't already a page
  71. Spring Lake (King County, Washington)Hughesdarren – Good review (and it's already been nommed at DYK!)
  72. Damn Fuck WallHughesdarren – Good CSD
  73. Big Dog (company)A412 – Might be biased because I approved it in AfC, but I didn't see any issues then either
  74. Job (play)A412 – Good review, solid play page
Good, Thanks! DreamRimmer (talk) 11:09, 9 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]