Wikipedia:Peer review/List of Friends episodes/archive1
| Toolbox |
|---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I believe this is far from WP:FLC but can be with some suggestions/ideas. Having looked at other featured lists similar to this, I have managed to add all production numbers on each episode and a summary of Nielsen ratings. Any comments will be appreciated, thanks, Lemonade51 (talk) 21:27, 28 February 2012 (UTC)
Comments
- Not convinced that logo image qualifies for fair use in this list of episodes. Removed.
- "This article is about the episodes of the TV series "Friends". For the characters of "Friends", see Characters of Friends." hat notes normally used to ensure there's no confusion. Why would I get confused between episodes and characters? And shouldn't it be "List of Friends characters"? Maybe a see also, or, I suspect, it'll be in a template at the bottom... Removed.
- "The American" -> normally wouldn't this be something like "The US..." to ensure all comers know which Americans we're dealing with? Replaced
- Make sure all the tables meet MOS:DTT.
- Since most of the sections have barely a few links, I would suggest a synopsis of each season is included. Done, shared from the main article.
- I would make all tables have same col widths from season to season. Done
- Season 10 appears to be missing information. Done, moved specials from the episodes.
- Check for WP:DASH issues in the viewing figures table. Done.
- Make date formats consistent in the refs. Done.
- Check ref 8, avoid bare URLs. Done.
- Check ref titles meet WP:DASH. Done.
- Check works (like USA Today) are in italics. Done.
- I'm moderately unclear where all the episodes, their writers, their prod codes etc are referenced. Done.