Wikipedia:Peer review/Romance (Luis Miguel album)/archive1

Romance (Luis Miguel album)

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch peer review

This peer review discussion has been closed.
. I'm listing this article for peer review as it was recently promoted a GA and I'm hoping I can get it to FA real soon. Any feedback is appreciated!

Thanks, Erick (talk) 22:13, 2 December 2014 (UTC)[reply]

Comments from WikiRedactor

So sorry that I haven't gotten to this sooner, I've been so busy! It appears that the disambiguation and external links tools are down as of this writing, so I will have to come back for those later on. In the meantime, some comments I have:

It doesn't really make a difference as far as the article itself goes, but since I like to keep the internal workings tight and organized, I would suggest getting rid of the extra spaces in the infobox.

Done

You can drop California in the infobox, since Hollywood is sufficient on its own.

Done

I would use the {{ubl}} template for the last, this, and next album parameters.

Done

"No Sé Tú" is a red link in three instances, and should be unlinked.

Done

The "Tour" subheading can be removed because it is short enough to fit within the existing "Promotion" heading, and will not make it too long of a section.

Done

"Album certifications" can be renamed "Certifications", and can be pulled out as its own heading.

Done

The album has certifications in several countries, but we only list chart information for the United States. Is there any way we can find some chart information for the international territories discussed?

There are no acceptable reliable charts for any Latin American countries at the time of the albums release (AMPROFON didn't have album charts back then and a thorough search on CAPIF came up nothing).

I noticed in a few of the references that AllMusic is italicized, although only printed works should be italicized in the citations.

Done

WikiRedactor (talk) 00:18, 11 December 2014 (UTC)[reply]

Thanks for the input WikiRedactor! On an unrelated note, it's great to see Fijacion Oral 1 will be the first Spanish-language album to be TFA! Erick (talk) 00:38, 11 December 2014 (UTC)[reply]